Last nights Resources and Reserves Committee tried to address the elephant in the room of the Civic Centre redevelopment budget.
Council recently had a meeting with community reps and the architect to discuss further plans for the space and what seemed to be emerging is that if Council took the cheap option i.e. $5.1 million we would be getting a far inferior product than if actually lashing out and doing the job properly for around $8million.
So the committee asked the architect to go away and bring us back costings on the $5mill model and the $8 mill model to facilitate better decision making.
Councillors have a habit of plucking unrelated figures out of the air and saying that's what we will spend on the project rather than having a project fully scoped and knowing what the real spend should be.
Examples;
Ullaldulla Harbour Walkway $1 million- well what will that get us- know body knows even today!
Shoalhaven Entertainment Centre $24 million- needed a $2.4 million renovation for toilets within the first 5 years plus additional funding to finish of the landscaping.
There are lots of cost effective reasons why we should look at improving the civic centre /library/ tourism centre all in one go-but one of the main reasons that I brought it up on the first place was that council gets contributions for the library from developers- and the library money could be leveraged to make a better project overall!.
I think there is room for compromise in this project that will have excellent outcomes for all three areas (I'm not including the senior citzs area as is it is pretty good) lets face it Ulladulla and surrounding areas which the library services has grown immensely since the library was first created. Modern libraries are not just about dusty books, they are places for people to meet, places for children to learn a passion for learning, researching for family history, Internet hot spots for small business people or travellers, a place to share skills not just a place where people are always whispering and the library shushing you.
Here are some of the comments made by Councillors;
Councillor Proudfoot, I don't support spending any more money than what is already in the budget- this project was never about new library space but about air conditioning and a kitchen. I warned everyone that this project would get bigger once the community are involved
Councillor Brumerskyji: Books are a thing of the past, everyone will have kindles and ipads just look at how that technology has exploded.
Councillor Watson: We should make it $8 million and pare back on the library- this project has been hi jacked by the library lobbyists and the extra space is a luxury that is not needed.
It seems to me that these Councillors are blinded by their own circumstances and just because they don't use the facilities doesn't mean that others don't. Just ask the mums with pre schoolers who enjoy the big book corner. The older people who can access magazines that aren't affordable in their weekly budget. The researchers of family history who support one another learning about computers and history in one go. or the school kid who needs help with a school report or assignment.
As a community we can stand by and watch our public buildings and services be run into the ground and create the very destiny that some councillors see( which then would give them a good business case to sell the land for private development).
Or
We can redevelop our building well and have something for everyone a real community hub in the centre of town a vibrant place where people want to be, get information, be entertained, enjoy an exhibition the options are endless and there is a classic example at Albury which boasts an award winning Library Museum which is always a hive of activity when I have visited.
Albury's award wining Library Museum pic by John Gollings |
1 comment:
Those Councillor comments are quite staggering. The library is such an important place for us. In fact it's my favourite place in Ulladulla.. When the library redevelopment was announced I was delighted, and also relieved that a major facility would be provided to ratepayers in the southern shoalhaven. I'm in Bawley and the Shoalhaven Entertainment Centre could not be more irrelevant to me. I hardly know any locals who have used it or even know where it is.
Post a Comment